Who will rule now?

  • Our Minecraft servers are offline but we will keep this forum online for any community communication. Site permissions for posting could change at a later date but will remain online.

G33ke

Community Engagement Team Representative
Joined
Jul 22, 2012
Messages
999
Reaction score
1,889
1.7.2 MCSG teeeechically doesn't exist yet. The way it works is pretty much a taped together plugin that makes 1.7.2 players able to connect to a 1.6.4 server. (Sort of, this is the reason why you can connect to any major server on 1.7.2 and 1.6.4) This means, when MCSG is 100% updated to Bukkit when it's stable, 1.6.4 will no longer be supported. Who knows if that version of Bukkit will support the knock-back ability given to fishing rods.

(I really hope I'm not misinformed and look like a complete idiot right now)

You are completely right.

You guys can confirm this yourself: Try to incorrectly craft a flint and steel with the materials in the wrong places with a 1.7 client: In 1.7, the recipe is shapeless, and your client will say "That's okay with me!" and the recipe will show up for a brief moment before disappearing. This is because the server is saying "That's not a real recipe" and denying you the ability to craft it. Thus, the server still thinks it's back in 1.6.4...because it is.


Fishing rods, however, will still work in 1.7, even when the server fully updates...or at least they should. Technically, there is a chance of them not working, but such has been true for any update since the beginning of Bukkit. It's all up to the CraftBukkit team, or the Spigot team, or whatever...(I don't know all the specifics.)
Though the internal layout of Minecraft has significantly changed from the last update, I find it unlikely that fishing rods won't work. In fact, to my knowledge, (Which is admittedly limited in some ways.) it's kind of impossible for Bukkit/Spigot/Whatever to not allow fishing rods to work unless they did some major reconfiguring of the core parts of themselves, as fishing rods working on players is merely a side-effect of what these server configurations are truly doing, not a feature. Though significant changes have to be made to fit 1.7's needs, I don't believe the places that will change significantly will be the exact same places that allow us the ability to use fishing rods on other players.
 

Burtry

Peacekeeper
Joined
Sep 3, 2013
Messages
1,040
Reaction score
1,569
You are completely right.

You guys can confirm this yourself: Try to incorrectly craft a flint and steel with the materials in the wrong places with a 1.7 client: In 1.7, the recipe is shapeless, and your client will say "That's okay with me!" and the recipe will show up for a brief moment before disappearing. This is because the server is saying "That's not a real recipe" and denying you the ability to craft it. Thus, the server still thinks it's back in 1.6.4...because it is.


Fishing rods, however, will still work in 1.7, even when the server fully updates...or at least they should. Technically, there is a chance of them not working, but such has been true for any update since the beginning of Bukkit. It's all up to the CraftBukkit team, or the Spigot team, or whatever...(I don't know all the specifics.)
Though the internal layout of Minecraft has significantly changed from the last update, I find it unlikely that fishing rods won't work. In fact, to my knowledge, (Which is admittedly limited in some ways.) it's kind of impossible for Bukkit/Spigot/Whatever to not allow fishing rods to work unless they did some major reconfiguring of the core parts of themselves, as fishing rods working on players is merely a side-effect of what these server configurations are truly doing, not a feature. Though significant changes have to be made to fit 1.7's needs, I don't believe the places that will change significantly will be the exact same places that allow us the ability to use fishing rods on other players.
2smart4me
 

Chaos_Slayer_

Survivor
Joined
Aug 15, 2013
Messages
172
Reaction score
104
You are completely right.

You guys can confirm this yourself: Try to incorrectly craft a flint and steel with the materials in the wrong places with a 1.7 client: In 1.7, the recipe is shapeless, and your client will say "That's okay with me!" and the recipe will show up for a brief moment before disappearing. This is because the server is saying "That's not a real recipe" and denying you the ability to craft it. Thus, the server still thinks it's back in 1.6.4...because it is.


Fishing rods, however, will still work in 1.7, even when the server fully updates...or at least they should. Technically, there is a chance of them not working, but such has been true for any update since the beginning of Bukkit. It's all up to the CraftBukkit team, or the Spigot team, or whatever...(I don't know all the specifics.)
Though the internal layout of Minecraft has significantly changed from the last update, I find it unlikely that fishing rods won't work. In fact, to my knowledge, (Which is admittedly limited in some ways.) it's kind of impossible for Bukkit/Spigot/Whatever to not allow fishing rods to work unless they did some major reconfiguring of the core parts of themselves, as fishing rods working on players is merely a side-effect of what these server configurations are truly doing, not a feature. Though significant changes have to be made to fit 1.7's needs, I don't believe the places that will change significantly will be the exact same places that allow us the ability to use fishing rods on other players.
I have no idea what you just said but it makes you look really smart.
"The best way to look smart, is to right a giant paragraph that no one wants to read because its so big."
-Chaos Slayer
 

inconceivable81

Platinum
Joined
Dec 23, 2012
Messages
3,001
Reaction score
1,545
Fishing rods still work fine, but there are also the flame throwers (me) and the people that learn to use the BSM to their advantage as a surprise attack, for example by running at people, but retreating after the first and second hits, and after the third continuously sprinting forwards and fighting. (Me)
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
242,188
Messages
2,449,241
Members
523,962
Latest member
Atasci