The Compromise of the islands

[egoldo]

Many people have been arguing on breeze, freeze, and also demon island. Most people either like it or despise it, I have never seen someone who thought the map was neutral in their eyes. For example, tg1 i don't hate it or like it. In my opinion we should remove freeze and demon island. The state being is that we are basically playing the same map. It would have been more enjoyment if we had different maps other than the island. Like the new map valleyside university everyone enjoys it. I don't know but i am just stating what a majority of people have in mind with the maps. <3

 

[Evil_Emo]

These maps are for fun as such. Majority of the players like the edited version of breeze due to the fact that new scenery is imminent. I must admit I do like breeze (and all of it's parodies). So yeah, people love breeze. In fact, several of my friends love breeze! So that just goes to show that we shouldn't remove them.

 

[DJsquare_3 (davidround)]

despite how long they have been out I still haven't played freeze or demon yet

 

[Evil_Emo]

despite how long they have been out I still haven't played freeze or demon yet

Wut..

 

[hobo1955]

I don't think they should stay. They are good builds but they ruin the whole theme of breeze island and replace is with something terrible.

 

[FuSioN]

White text can't be seen on mobile. Please change.

 

[KorStonesword]

I think that Breeze and Demon's Breeze should stay (and in my opinion Demon's Breeze should replace Breeze, but I know that will never happen ) but Freeze Island should be removed.

 

[Vaangel]

Many people have been arguing on breeze, freeze, and also demon island. Most people either like it or despise it, I have never seen someone who thought the map was neutral in their eyes. For example, tg1 i don't hate it or like it. In my opinion we should remove freeze and demon island. The state being is that we are basically playing the same map. It would have been more enjoyment if we had different maps other than the island. Like the new map valleyside university everyone enjoys it. I don't know but i am just stating what a majority of people have in mind with the maps. <3

Be careful with the using of "everyone", "everyone" does not like Valleyside University. A large amount of people do, but not everyone. Good point though.

I don't think they should stay. They are good builds but they ruin the whole theme of breeze island and replace is with something terrible.

You rock Hobo. Keep on posting stuff like this.

 

[egoldo]

Be careful with the using of "everyone", "everyone" does not like Valleyside University. A large amount of people do, but not everyone. Good point though.
You rock Hobo. Keep on posting stuff like this.

true.

 

[hwracer]

Overplayed map?
Their solution is:

Add more Breeze Islands but with snow and lava

The hell?

 

[Mamiamato24]

I've seen so many posts about the removal of Freeze Island and Demon's Breeze, and honestly, please stop. It's not very nice when map-makers see dozens of threads requesting for their map's removal. I understand we don't all like the maps, but they were chosen to be MCSG maps, which is exceptional because only a slim number of maps made get accepted. I think they are both amazing maps, and I request they stay in MCSG.

I'd also like to explain why they were added in the first place. We all know the almighty Breeze Island is overplayed like hell. We got that down. But you have to realize, that Breeze Island is overplayed because people like it, and if it was a shitty map then nobody would be playing it. Adding two variants of Breeze Island was actually an amazing idea! Why, you may ask? Because it gives people the best of both worlds. If you like Breeze, but hate water chases, and love short chases, then Demon's Breeze is the map for you. If you like long chases, but don't like Breeze, then try Freeze Island.

Think of it as a video game company market share. One console is being bought so much, that the other consoles are so scarcely bought and played. Then two new, and similar, consoles are released. Some people switch, and the over purchased console begins to loose market share. Now, the purchases are more evenly distributed, so now they are relatively almost equal. This is kind of what they were planning to do.

I know it really removes Breeze Island's "uniqueness", but people were so pissed off of that map that something eventually had to be done, and something was done. It's simple really; if you don't like a map that's about to be played, then leave the lobby, and join another server. It's not difficult. I know some people detest the new maps, but everybody hates maps. Those are personal opinions. Some people adore these maps, and are devastated to hear that there is a chance for their removal. There won't ever be a map that everybody likes, so in conclusion, the maps should stay. POINT MADE.

Kthxbai,
Mamiamato24

 

[Vaangel]

Overplayed map?
Their solution is:

Add more Breeze Islands but with snow and lava

The hell?

Worst idea ever.