Boombeard's battle needs to be removed...

[Dantelius]

I was playing on this on he skydoes minecraft server, and it was a nice map, so whatif the tiers are messed up, that can be fixed, and who cares if he hes not played mcsg. Its a decent map, though not my favourite.
stop moaning it took a long time to make an is probably better han whag yku could do.
it tales a lot of time to fix things up like tiers, but they eventually will get done...

I'm pretty sure I could make a better one considering half of their map is water.

 

[screacher90]

So is Breeze, and yet that it one of the most overplayed maps. So I suppose people think differently?



That's because if you jump on the pressure plate on your pedetisal it gives you a boat to sail to corn with. Everyone can do that at the moment. (We are releasing a new version of the map soon without any boats however).

And even if 6 people did spawn at corn, that wouldn't be a reason to remove the map. It would be a plug-in problem, not the maps.



Actually...

Now, look at overplayed Breeze...

That's double... And how is tier 2 count a reason to remove a map?




We were thinking this looked cool:

​

As for the enchanted armor, we know about it. In the new version we're releasing later today, there will be no boats nor OP items.

And again, why is OP items a reason to remove a map? It still looks... well, look above.

Love you ily <3

 

[Cubes]

I'm pretty sure I could make a better one considering half of their map is water.

MCSG would love to have new map submissions
The more the merrier

 

[EvermoreHD]

The terraforming is horrid on this map. The map is basically a lot of poorly terraformed islands in a huge ocean. Not the kind of map that should be added if MCSG wants to improve their map standards.

 

[Cubes]

To all:

Please discontinue the constant flame on this map. While we here at MCSG believe that everyone is entitled to their own opinions and feelings regarding maps and other topics of conversation, that doesn't condone doing nothing but showing public distaste. Please try to keep all criticism constructive and beneficial.

Bad:
Dude, this map sucks. How could MCSG even add this?

Good:
Here is a well thought out selection of some key points of the map that I believe could be improved upon.
I've provided sound and supportive reasoning as to why my opinions stand, but I do not mock the opinions of others or the creators.

Good day

 

[Bamber]

I think it looks pretty good!

I mean, this is the survival games, right?? Correct me if Im wrong, but isn't this supposed to be based on the movie? Where the maps are HUGE and have 2 week games? I like the fact that this map adds a feeling of survival to these servers. On other maps, you get about 5 chests that are out in the open and you are instantly suited up with food and basic needs (wooden weapon at least, couple of pieces of leather armor).

Most maps are just purely PVP based. This one is actually quite cool in terms of being survival related with a decent amount of PvP.
I find it much more rewarding to win a difficult game where I had poor loot than a quick one where I got completely looted up off corn.


Forgive my English, but I think I shared my opinion correctly, no?

 

[Dantelius]

MCSG would love to have new map submissions
The more the merrier

I actually am making a map, haha.

 

[chockadlad]

So is Breeze, and yet that it one of the most overplayed maps. So I suppose people think differently?



That's because if you jump on the pressure plate on your pedetisal it gives you a boat to sail to corn with. Everyone can do that at the moment. (We are releasing a new version of the map soon without any boats however).

And even if 6 people did spawn at corn, that wouldn't be a reason to remove the map. It would be a plug-in problem, not the maps.



Actually...

Now, look at overplayed Breeze...

That's double... And how is tier 2 count a reason to remove a map?




We were thinking this looked cool:

​

As for the enchanted armor, we know about it. In the new version we're releasing later today, there will be no boats nor OP items.

And again, why is OP items a reason to remove a map? It still looks... well, look above.

While I do agree that it looks very cool from that point of view, I think that the map committee should look from all perspectives.

 

[Dantelius]

Actually...

Now, look at overplayed Breeze...

Theoretical, Breeze is a classic map, and there are ways to avoid the water, in Boombeard's battle, it's hard to avoid the water and have fast games because the islands are so small, so it requires you to swim a lot, there's also a decently cave system underground, which makes games longer. And the tier 2 to tier 1 ratio is higher than Boombeard's battle. And I feel that Boombeard's battle is a bigger map.

 

[Theoretical]

Actually...

Now, look at overplayed Breeze...

Theoretical, Breeze is a classic map, and there are ways to avoid the water, in Boombeard's battle, it's hard to avoid the water and have fast games because the islands are so small, so it requires you to swim a lot, there's also a decently cave system underground, which makes games longer. And the tier 2 to tier 1 ratio is higher than Boombeard's battle. And I feel that Boombeard's battle is a bigger map.

What's bad about having a map that takes a long time?

Also Breeze is waaaay bigger.
If you look here:
http://www.minecraftsurvivalgames.com/threads/survival-games-breeze-island.10912
It says it's a 500 block map, while on
http://www.planetminecraft.com/project/boombeards-battle/
It says it's a 320 block map.

 

[TheCornStealer]

I haven't played that map yet and if they do remove it, make sure I've got a win on it first

 

[Dantelius]

What's bad about having a map that takes a long time?

Also Breeze is waaaay bigger.
If you look here:
http://www.minecraftsurvivalgames.com/threads/survival-games-breeze-island.10912
It says it's a 500 block map, while on
http://www.planetminecraft.com/project/boombeards-battle/
It says it's a 320 block map.

Nothing against long games, like I love sg classic, ( I'm like ranked 7th and haven't played it in a week) but normally when I play regular sg I'm looking for fast games. (Besides clan battles) Breeze island is also a lot faster because it's easy to find the middle of the map, where as Boombeard's battle is somewhat difficult to find the spawn.