Boombeard's battle needs to be removed...

[KorStonesword]

While I find that reasonable, that's you. That's not everyone. By that standard, we shouldn't have SG1, SG2, SG3, SG5, The Fallen Empire and Fortune Island on regular SG. Those all take awhile.

And you notice most people don't like any of those maps? imo, SG1 = Only good on SGClassic, SG2 = Okay, but better on SGClassic, SG3 = Only really fun in 120p, SG5 = crap *flush*, Fallen Empire = eh, its ok, Fortune Island = ok.

 

[reven86]

Thats why there is a Deathmatch arena, and it works, if it's bugged and does not, that's some good info.



As said above, this is not our fault, blaming us and complaining is a hopeless cause. As I also said, coordinates would be much appreciated.



A valid argument, I may start work on making the corn an actual Island.



This part is my bad; I saw the amount of water on the map and thought "Hmm, what could I do so that everyone can navigate the map better? Maybe make it so everyone starts out with boats!". This idea worked until I realized that using a boat bypasses the podium holding you back. I attempted removing them but the maps were already being pushed, I will get the time in the next week to make sure that's fixed.

Not blaming you for anything as far as the map . I know it was all the map makers fault for the items being placed in the map, just like the swords/enchanting bottles on wyverns. Not blaming staff for anything .

Yes also, both times I played the map, the dm arena didn't work. So I didn't even know it even had one . That makes it a lil better when that gets fixed.

If you guys would put a decent sized island at corn, I think the map would actually be liked somewhat. Like I said, it looks nice, it just needs to be more pvp friendly and balanced.

I also understand your interest in the boats at spawn. It's a unique idea for map such as that. My suggestion, is simply to maybe put the boats in a dispenser at corn by the chests . That away if you don't get a chest at corn, you got a chance of getting a boat instead. It kind of makes it more strategic. You can either get the chests at corn.. and swim your way around the map.. or get the boats, and get to the other islands more quickly for goods loots .

 

[TheManWithFire]

True! played it ones and it suck. Couldent get any gear and i had a wood sword a Leather helmet. Corn sucks also. They must remove it

 

[Theoretical]

And you notice most people don't like any of those maps? imo, SG1 = Only good on SGClassic, SG2 = Okay, but better on SGClassic, SG3 = Only really fun in 120p, SG5 = crap *flush*, Fallen Empire = eh, its ok, Fortune Island = ok.

You sure? Then why do we have them?

 

[KorStonesword]

You sure? Then why do we have them?

Nobody hates them enough to want them removed, and most people have never played them either because they're never voted. Seriously, the few times I actually get into SG5 before leaving, at least 2 people say 'I've never played this map before.'

 

[Theoretical]

Nobody hates them enough to want them removed, and most people have never played them either because they're never voted. Seriously, the few times I actually get into SG5 before leaving, at least 2 people say 'I've never played this map before.'

No it's because they are good quality maps, maybe not game play wise, but aesthetically. That's why they are not played.

 

[Cat_On_A_Poptart]

It's not that bad, but there's minor issues that do need to be fixed I can tell :/

 

[KorStonesword]

No it's because they are good quality maps, maybe not game play wise, but aesthetically. That's why they are not played.

Looks aren't everything, gameplay is much more important, that's why I said nobody likes them. I'm speaking for the majority here, I personally like SG2.

 

[Zietra]

And you notice most people don't like any of those maps? imo, SG1 = Only good on SGClassic, SG2 = Okay, but better on SGClassic, SG3 = Only really fun in 120p, SG5 = crap *flush*, Fallen Empire = eh, its ok, Fortune Island = ok.

Tbh, those maps belongs to mcsg. I love seeing them, and i still vote for them and I know alot of others do too. And also, new players want the chance to play them?

 

[Echo/Haydn]

But still.. It's a huge water fight map, where teams clearly dominate. It's hard to dodge arrows because the water is only 5 blocks deep... So bows will dominate, especially with the low amount of tier 2 chests.

Another note: The creator of the map hasn't played a single MCSG game... (unless I spelled their name wrong - which I'm pretty sure I didn't)

Why would they accept a map by someone who hasn't played mcsg once? >.<. They knew there would be problems with the map.

OMG I fail on my phone with quoting. Hahahha[/quote]
He's never played MCSG, probably because he doesnt know what MCGamer is, as the map was taken off Planet Minecraft. The Map Committee don't just choose maps on the MCGamer Forums, they look all around.

 

[Dantelius]

What have I done..

 

[HugBabyBearBear]

Well, there's a new crappy map called Boombeard's battle. First off, all of Corn is water, along with 50% of the map. How is that suppose to be fun? 2nd off, 6 people spawn in the beginning of the game right next to the Corn chests, making it impossible for the others to get the chests. 3rd off, there are no other tier 2's in the whole map, maybe like 1 or 2... 4th off, you can get a diamond chestplate, WTF was mcsg thinking when they accepted this map?!?!

http://puu.sh/5F1ki.jpg- People spawn right next to Corn Chests, And a crappy Cornucopia, because of trying to make 2 Cornucopias. (FAIL)

http://puu.sh/5F2mT.jpg - You can get a diamond chestplate, Enchanted... Seems legit. Please remove this map, for it is probably the worse map in MCSG... By far. Whoever made this should not get their VIP.

Edit: EMEMERRRGODDDD, 10 likes. I'm so popular. I'm flattered.

Ermagherd Catching Fire corn is also 50% water