If you don't have the brain to realize that you shouldn't post things like that, keep quiet.
Mods don't always have to be right with their opinions on maps, and I'm sorry, but I don't think they said that they LOVED the map.
I will try to give you constructive critic only, remember that this is my own personal opinion.
The map could use alot of terraforming. There's water everywhere, except for a few places where there's a very small amount of islands and buildings.
The detailing done on the buildings is very poorly done. Look at the creeper temple building for example. A square shaped building with a lime green creeper head placed on top of it. The colors don't match each other at all, and the exterior of the temple itself... some vines? I know that a large amount of accepted maps lack nice looking buildings and detailing, but that is not something you should aim for. ANYBODY can make decent looking exterior if they try their best. EVERYONE. I don't think you tried your best to make this map look fantastic. You built square shaped houses with some windows. I know that you can do better, and so do you.
If you want to have this map put on the servers, you have to place alot more chests. The average player finds at least two chests every game, not including cornucopia chest. If 24 players would play on this map at the same time with this small amount of chests, then one lucky guy would be likely to get a little less than a third of all the loot after getting a few kills.
There you have it, constructive critic at its finest. I do not believe this map is ready for MCSG, not yet. Good luck with it and trust in yourselves, you are only as good as you let yourself be.
Off topic:
To all of you who says that a specific map "sucks" (
innvisableninja) without so much as explaining why it "sucks", take a break from the Internet and be ashamed of yourselves. You might have made someone else's day a bit worse. Use your brains.