Boombeard's battle needs to be removed...

[iDufferz]

Well, there's a new crappy map called Boombeard's battle. First off, all of Corn is water, along with 50% of the map. How is that suppose to be fun? 2nd off, 6 people spawn in the beginning of the game right next to the Corn chests, making it impossible for the others to get the chests. 3rd off, there are no other tier 2's in the whole map, maybe like 1 or 2... 4th off, you can get a diamond chestplate, WTF was mcsg thinking when they accepted this map?!?!

http://puu.sh/5F1ki.jpg- People spawn right next to Corn Chests, And a crappy Cornucopia, because of trying to make 2 Cornucopias. (FAIL)

http://puu.sh/5F2mT.jpg - You can get a diamond chestplate, Enchanted... Seems legit. Please remove this map, for it is probably the worse map in MCSG... By far. Whoever made this should not get their VIP.

xD some guy in the first picture said: is this a new mat?????

 

[Theoretical]

I agree, this map should be removed.

Can you at least give your reasons?

 

[SirCumstances]

Even if there were bridges added between the islands and ships, I would be happy. While the map is not my favorite, some minor changes could make it more enjoyable.

 

[EditingXBL]

Okay, the people who spawn next to corn at the start will be fixed and I'm sure it is fixed. The diamond chest plate probably 100% will be removed because that's just really OP and stupid. *Cough, cough*. KBYE, LLAMA SWAG2k17 IS OUT

 

[PikachuPals]

This map is a good map. When the boats at corn and the OP armour is gone, it would be a very good map .

 

[Angryjukebox]

With a pirate map water is not 'avoidable', and the person who built this map doesn't play MCSG, so he wouldn't know.

Ignorance is no excuse

 

[reven86]

Just as I stated in my last post about this map.. it truely does need removed.. or at least revamped.

Overpowered and unfair start to the map with people getting boats. Not very good chest routes in general. But the ones that are there, are overpowered as heck. Deathmatch there is completely miserable... No one wants to fight in pure water in dm... most annoying thing in the world... Also the overpowered enchanted diamond chestplate.. come on -.-

Only thing that the map has going for it.. is it looks nice at some points(volcano, ships). But it really comes down to pvp and balance... both of which the map is lacking in.

With a pirate map water is not 'avoidable', and the person who built this map doesn't play MCSG, so he wouldn't know.

The problem with all the water is the fact that the map.. is centered around water. breeze island is centered with the actual island.. and water surrounds you. In this map.. you start off in the water.. Also, deathmatch is completely water based... its even worse than breeze lol. At least breeze has a decent sized area around the water you can fight people in.. instead of a pure water fight.

EDIT: Apparently there is a proper dm arena but it is glitched occasionally. So no problems with dm if this bug is fixed.

If they would.. remove the weird boat thing at corn... which is a huge disadvantage to people who haven't played the map b4, or new to mcsg, and remade corn.. to actually have some land.. xD. I think the map wouldn't get so much rage.

 

[Goldenpig101]

If it was put onto mcsg, some people had to like the map and also you most of the water is 1 block deep so it is super hard to PVP. People used boats before the game starts to get to spawn which was really stupid. Lastly the chests, there weren't many chests but there were no tier 2's like Vida Cova (If anybody knows a tier 2 on Vida Cova tell me). Yet I had to leave right before deathmatch when I played this map for the only time I played it. Good for you if you have a good route on this map with the chestplate.

Edit: This map is Ok. Dantelius, you should find out the names of the creators right when the lobby ends. Just a tip

 

[Theoretical]

Ignorance is no excuse

Amen.

Just as I stated in my last post about this map.. it truely does need removed.. or at least revamped.

Overpowered and unfair start to the map with people getting boats. Not very good chest routes in general. But the ones that are there, are overpowered as heck. Deathmatch there is completely miserable... No one wants to fight in pure water in dm... most annoying thing in the world... Also the overpowered enchanted diamond chestplate.. come on -.-

Only thing that the map has going for it.. is it looks nice at some points(volcano, ships). But it really comes down to pvp and balance... both of which the map is lacking in.



The problem with all the water is the fact that the map.. is centered around water. breeze island is centered with the actual island.. and water surrounds you. In this map.. you start off in the water.. Also, deathmatch is completely water based... its even worse than breeze lol. At least breeze has a decent sized area around the water you can fight people in.. instead of a pure water fight.

If they would.. remove the weird boat thing at corn... which is a huge disadvantage to people who haven't played the map b4, or new to mcsg, and remade corn.. to actually have some land.. xD. I think the map wouldn't get so much rage.

Gotta love a good arguement.

 

[qwErtyVAsdfghN]

Look. There are so many threads telling you not to do exactly this. Imagine if you were a mapmaker who just got your map accepted into MCSG. You've probably spent months working on it. The day after it gets accepted, there are threads like these. "Remove Insert Map Here!" "Insert Map Here Sux!" Next time you make a thread like this, think about other people.

 

[Toast]

http://puu.sh/5F1ki.jpg- People spawn right next to Corn Chests, And a crappy Cornucopia, because of trying to make 2 Cornucopias. (FAIL).

We never tried to add a second corn, the corn design is a byproduct of the original corn design (which is one of the most creative things I've seen) not working with our plugin.

http://puu.sh/5F2mT.jpg - You can get a diamond chestplate, Enchanted... Seems legit.

This was unknown until now, if you find the coordinates to the chestplate, that will help us to remove it. Complaining will not help get somehing fixed.

Please remove this map, for it is probably the worse map in MCSG... By far. Whoever made this should not get their VIP.

Opinions are opinions, and saying someone does not deserve VIP because of that opinion is uncalled for.

One of the most despised things in MCSG, water.
So what do they do to amaze the community? Add a map that's basically all water.

So you're basically saying you want breeze removed, which is fine (I personally agree), but what would happen if we did?

They should be removed.

Reason: I hate them xD

1 person's opinion does not dictate the need to remove a map/maps.

Even if there were bridges added between the islands and ships, I would be happy. While the map is not my favorite, some minor changes could make it more enjoyable.

Not a bad idea, we do have full permission to edit this map:

Deathmatch there is completely miserable... No one wants to fight in pure water in dm... most annoying thing in the world...

Thats why there is a Deathmatch arena, and it works, if it's bugged and does not, that's some good info.

Also the overpowered enchanted diamond chestplate.. come on -.-

As said above, this is not our fault, blaming us and complaining is a hopeless cause. As I also said, coordinates would be much appreciated.

The problem with all the water is the fact that the map.. is centered around water. breeze island is centered with the actual island.. and water surrounds you. In this map.. you start off in the water..

A valid argument, I may start work on making the corn an actual Island.

.

If they would.. remove the weird boat thing at corn... which is a huge disadvantage to people who haven't played the map b4, or new to mcsg, and remade corn.. to actually have some land.. xD. I think the map wouldn't get so much rage.

This part is my bad; I saw the amount of water on the map and thought "Hmm, what could I do so that everyone can navigate the map better? Maybe make it so everyone starts out with boats!". This idea worked until I realized that using a boat bypasses the podium holding you back. I attempted removing them but the maps were already being pushed, I will get the time in the next week to make sure that's fixed.

 

[Tironas11]

Since the opinions of the map makers obviously do matter (and while from what I can see, the map doesn't look like it'd be fitted to the community's needs due to the excess amount of water) and this thread obviously has gotten out of control, I'd want to see a new feature on the servers regarding the map selections. The map committee was a fantastic addition to the servers, don't get me wrong, but another way to deter these types of threads is having a sort of "trial period" for the maps.

These trial periods would only last 1-2 weeks and they'd be released onto the servers (or we could allocate 10 servers from lesser played gametypes and have them exclusively be trial map servers) for people to critique. At the end of the 1-2 weeks, there would be a poll released onto the servers in which the community can vote on. Obviously, whichever opinion gets the most votes determines the fate of the map on the server. This way, the map creators can go back to the drawing board with their map and make changes based on (hopefully) helpful critique from the forum community. (The critique would be enforced by the staff team a little more harshly so the harmful bashing that I've seen on this thread and other threads wouldn't ensue throughout the forums.)

Just a suggestion, feel free to reply to my post. I don't think the community gets a lot of say in the map selection process and that's something that I'd like to see change so these types of threads don't happen again.



***EDIT*** seems like someone already beat me to it, please give this thread appreciation! http://www.minecraftsurvivalgames.com/threads/map-testing-before-implementation.72588/