If you had to judge SG1 like you judge new submissions...

[Cubes]

What would you say if you gave feedback on SG1. Keep in mind to hit on the same points that you would for the new maps that people submit.

 

[Toast]

Pfft, SG1 would be crushed.

 

[Cubes]

Pfft, SG1 would be crushed.

The point exactly. XD

 

[flyon21]

Why's it so big.... Why so many trees..... Nothing exciting..... Y U DO DIS

 

[MJM239]

If SG1 were submitted now, there'd be absolutely zero chance of acceptance.

- Too large.
- Too much water.
- Not enough structures, and the structures that are made are kind of mediocre.
- Oh yeah, and trees. I'M TALKING TO YOU HELL GAMES.

But SG1 is still one of my favorite maps, cause come on, it's a classic. Not to mention it's the only map that actually follows through with a legitimate Hunger Games idea, and succeeds.

 

[VeeZa]

I'd say that it needs more structures, more terraforming and less trees in some areas and that it is too big. The way it is now, I don't think it wouldn't get accepted. Although I love the map, it isn't good enough to be accepted if it were submitted today.

 

[Toast]

- Oh yeah, and trees. I'M TALKING TO YOU HELL GAMES.

This is a very serious question.

HOW THE HELL AM I NOT THE #1 MOST HATED IN MCSG FOR MAKING THAT MAP?!?!?!?!?!?!?

Jeez, I know people don't like it, cut me some slack ;_____;

 

[duckluv321]

With today's current themes, and expectations-- SG 1 would be definitely in the tough. I do believe however, myself included, that if it were to be removed, many people would be disappointed. For the people who've been in-game since beta-- that's like a home of sorts. That map was what started off on these servers, and really what started the "Survial Games/Hunger Games" frenzy in minecrsft.

I will always have a love for that map no matter what, simply for the fact I actually do enjoy playing on it, and it's like a piece of history. That was the first map, and that's something most people will never forget

 

[Ninetailefox92]

I do agree with what people have been saying, but I love sg1! I think it has amazing gameplay

 

[EvermoreHD]

I love SG1 for not necessarily the building or terraforming, but the gameplay and secrets.

 

[Fnnythe3hd]

I'm really glad that I was there for beta. I asked one of my friends who had just started playing MCSG for their thoughts on the map they replied with "It's awful", and "Not creative enough". I love the map, and it'll always be my favorite.

 

[ShaunDepro]

Depends if there was already another wilderness-like map on the servers, if not then I'd like it for terraforming, structures, traps and puzzles, it's got no flaw except for the water covering half the map...